‘Sexualised’ niqab hero gets makeover after costume criticism

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

'Sexualised' niqab hero gets makeover after costume criticism

Image copyright Sara Alfageeh

Sara Alfageeh, from Boston, USA, has always loved comics. As a child, she used to "run home from the library with stacks of them".

But the recent depiction of one character annoyed her so much she chose to take matters into her own hands.

In a tweet, Ms Alfageeh vented her frustration with the way the X-Men character Dust was drawn.

Dust, a mutant from Afghanistan, is described by Marvel as having a strong "respect for tradition".

Ms Alfageeh shared an image of Dust and asked: "Who looked at a niqabi character and still gave her the latex costume treatment?"

Image Copyright @TheFoofinator @TheFoofinator Report
Twitter post by @TheFoofinator: y'know. I love comics. I do, I really do. but wow y'all. who signed off on this Dust art. who looked at a niqabi character and still gave her the latex costume treatment. I'm laughing so damn hard oh my god. Image Copyright @TheFoofinator @TheFoofinator Report

The question clearly hit a nerve with many other comic book fans.

A number agreed that the design of Dust's outfit was not reflective of a realistic niqab and took issue with the form-fitting outfit.

Image Copyright @Shubbabang @Shubbabang Report
Twitter post by @Shubbabang: Vacuum sealed Niqab, because why not I guess Image Copyright @Shubbabang @Shubbabang Report

Ms Alfageeh told the BBC she was annoyed the artist had "felt the need to sexualise Dust" and make her "clothes cling to her body".

One Twitter user said: "No female artist would ever pretend that's how boobs work."

While another pointed out having tight material on one's chest would be "so uncomfortable in the desert".

Twitter user Anile expressed concern that the tightness of Dust's abaya (long robe) would restrict the superhero's ability to breathe.

Image Copyright @Anilelicious @Anilelicious Report
Twitter post by @Anilelicious: Poor thing. How can she breath under this tight abaya????? Image Copyright @Anilelicious @Anilelicious Report

Ms Alfageeh, "fuelled by bitterness and a deep love of street fashion", decided to take matters into her own hands and redesign the hero's attire – echoing a recent trend on social media to redraw comic book characters seen as sexist.

Image copyright Sara Alfageeh

Her images of Dust have been liked nearly 20,000 times on Twitter. And hundreds of people have replied to praise the "amazing" images.

Many young Muslim women commented to applaud the fashionable designs.

Image Copyright @AmyRoko @AmyRoko Report
Twitter post by @AmyRoko: stop I can’tI want to dress like this now Image Copyright @AmyRoko @AmyRoko Report
Image Copyright @sanya01 @sanya01 Report
Twitter post by @sanya01: Fabulous, absolutely love this. Image Copyright @sanya01 @sanya01 Report

While most responses to Ms Alfageeh's tweet were to congratulate her, others pointed out the superhero remained "problematic".

Despite being a popular character in the X-Men universe, Dust has previously drawn criticism for being poorly researched.

For example, Marvel lists her place of origin as an "unrevealed location in western Afghanistan".

However, Dust speaks in Arabic, rather than Pashto or Dari, which are much more commonly spoken in Afghanistan.

You may also like:

  • What's the difference between a hijab, niqab and burka?
  • Florida shooting: Gaming community reacts
  • School's 'unnatural hair' rule criticised

Ms Alfageeh's images have caught the attention of a number of high-profile comic book authors.

Zac Thompson, who has written a number of Marvel comics including editions of the X-Men series, replied to the tweeted designs to say they were "dope".

Image Copyright @ZacBeThompson @ZacBeThompson Report
Twitter post by @ZacBeThompson: This is so dope. Image Copyright @ZacBeThompson @ZacBeThompson Report

Ms Alfageeh, who is an artist, said the positive reaction had been "really exciting".

She said she had known she had "nailed it" when young Muslim women told her they identified with the outfits.

"I wanted to give Dust lots of attitude in my drawings." she said.

"A woman who wears the niqab needs that attitude and thick skin just to walk down the street."

The images also started a conversation about the importance of "diverse creators" who were able to properly reflect the cultural backgrounds of characters.

Image Copyright @MarvelMutantX @MarvelMutantX Report
Twitter post by @MarvelMutantX: Dust is such a great character and this is a perfect example of why diverse creators are needed. I love these and adore the first one! #XMenMonday pay attention, dear @cracksh0t Image Copyright @MarvelMutantX @MarvelMutantX Report

Ms Alfageeh agrees it's hard to represent different cultures authentically when those people aren't "involved in the creative process".

Marvel has introduced more LGBT and ethnic minority characters in recent years, including Ms Marvel – a young Muslim woman.

Ms Marvel has been well received by fans. And Ms Alfageeh agrees that the hero is an example of Marvel succeeding in representing minority groups with "well written three-dimensional characters".

She jokingly said she was "doing it for the kids" but very seriously believes that the young people "carrying stacks of comics" like she did have "every right" to feel represented.

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.